What Are the Disadvantages of Vinyl Plank Flooring?

Vinyl plank flooring has become one of the most popular choices in Toronto homes and condos, thanks to its affordability, water resistance, and realistic wood-like appearance. But while this flooring type offers several advantages, it’s not without its downsides.
If you're considering vinyl plank flooring for your space, it's important to understand not just what it does well—but also where it falls short. In this article, we’ll explore the most common disadvantages of vinyl plank flooring so you can make an informed decision before your next installation.

Limited Lifespan Compared to Hardwood or Tile

While vinyl plank flooring can last 10–20 years with proper care, it doesn't match the durability or longevity of natural materials like solid hardwood floor or ceramic tile. Over time, wear and tear such as surface scratches, dents, and fading can develop—especially in high-traffic areas or under heavy furniture.
For homeowners in Toronto planning long-term investments in their properties, this may be a disadvantage. Vinyl flooring is often seen as a mid-range solution—not something intended to last a lifetime like hardwood flooring might.

Vinyl Flooring Repairs Are Not Easy

Unlike hardwood, which can be sanded and refinished multiple times, vinyl plank flooring is not designed for refinishing. If a section gets damaged—whether from deep scratches, heat, or water intrusion—it typically needs to be replaced entirely.
In glue-down vinyl flooring, replacing a single plank can be particularly labor-intensive. Even in click-lock systems, in order to repair damaged vinyl plank flooring sections properly and replace them, a 100% perfect match of exact same material is needed, which in a lot of cases, specially after many years, it is not always available. In that case, a full floor replacement is needed, which can be costly.
This lack of repair flexibility makes vinyl plank flooring less forgiving in busy households or commercial settings where damage may be more likely.

Can Be Susceptible to Subfloor Imperfections

Vinyl plank flooring—especially the click lock systems - requires a smooth, level subfloor for proper installation. Any bumps, dips, or debris under the planks can telegraph through the flooring surface, creating visible imperfections over time, and may break the click system.
In older Toronto condos and homes, where subfloors may be uneven or damaged, extra preparation is often needed. This can increase both the time and cost of installation. Without proper prep, the flooring may wear unevenly, feel unstable underfoot, or even lead to premature failure.

Can Be Prone to Discoloration

Over time, vinyl plank flooring can discolor due to prolonged exposure to direct sunlight or certain household chemicals. UV rays can cause fading or yellowing, particularly in rooms with large windows and no UV protection.
Rubber materials—like mats or furniture feet—can also react with the vinyl surface, leaving permanent stains or dark spots. This is especially important in commercial spaces or condo units with rubber-backed area rugs, which can accelerate discoloration.
To reduce the risk, it’s recommended to use window coverings, non-rubber mats, and proper cleaners approved for vinyl flooring.

Is Vinyl Plank Flooring Still Worth It in Toronto?

Despite its drawbacks, vinyl plank flooring remains one of the most popular choices for Toronto homes and condos—especially in high-moisture areas like basements, kitchens, and rental units. The affordability, durability, and wide design range often outweigh the concerns for many property owners.
However, being aware of its limitations—like susceptibility to fading, lack of recyclability, and challenges with repairs—is crucial for setting the right expectations.
If you’re looking for long-lasting, water-resistant, and low-maintenance flooring, vinyl plank is a solid contender. Just be sure to:

• Choose high-quality planks (ideally ≥7mm thick)
• Consider glue-down installations for commercial or high-traffic use

For expert guidance and flooring installation in Toronto, reach out to us at Parqueteam Hardwood Flooring—we’ll help you select the right flooring solution for your space.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is vinyl plank flooring a good choice for Toronto homes?
Yes, it’s a popular choice due to its water resistance and affordability. However, it’s important to weigh the drawbacks—like difficulty in repairs — before choosing it over hardwood or laminate floors.

Does vinyl plank flooring lower home value?
Not necessarily. While it's not as prestigious as solid hardwood floors or engineered hardwood floors, quality vinyl planks can still appeal to buyers—especially in condos, rentals, and basement spaces.

Can vinyl plank flooring be repaired if damaged?
It depends on the type. Glue-down planks are easier to replace individually, while click-lock planks often require partial disassembly. Either way, repairs are more complex than with traditional hardwood floors.

How long does vinyl plank flooring last in a Toronto climate?
High-quality vinyl flooring can last 15–25 years, especially when professionally installed and maintained. However, direct sunlight, moisture buildup, and heavy furniture can shorten its lifespan.

Can vinyl planks handle Toronto winters and indoor heating?
They perform well indoors, but avoid installations in unheated spaces like enclosed porches or sunrooms. Sudden temperature swings can cause expansion and contraction.